REPORT OF THE EXTERNAL REVIEW COMMITTEE
ON THE STATISTICAL SEISMOLOGY RESEARCH
1.1 External Review Committee
1.2 Statistical Seismology Research Group
1.3 Terms of Reference
Quality and impact of academic activities
Statistical theory and methodology
1.4 Seismological theory and methodology
2 Cooperative research activities and contribution to the public good
2.1 Interinstitute activities
2.2 Contributions to the public good
3 Bringing up the next generation
4 Comments and suggestions for the future work plan
5 Overall conclusions and recommendations
Appendix 1: Schedule of External Review
Appendix 2: Summary of materials presented the Review Committee
Appendix 3: Programme of the 4th International Workshop on Statistical Seismology
1.1 External Review Committee
The members of the committee and their home institutions are as follows.
Nazionale di Geofisica e
Prevention Research Institute,
Earthquake Research Institute, The
and Statistical Research
1.2 Statistical Seismology Research Group
List of members including postdocs and graduate students is as follows
Yosihiko Ogata The Institute of Statistical Mathematics (ISM) (Leader)
Shinji Toda Visiting Prof. of the ISM (2005--)
Geological Survey of
Yasuaki MURATA Visiting Assoc. Prof. of the ISM (2003--2004)
Geological Survey of
Jiancang Zhuang Research Fellow upon JSPS program (2001 -- 2005)
Kazuyoshi Nanjo Research Fellow upon JSPS program (2003 --)
Takaki Iwata Research Fellow of ISM (2005 --)
Masatsugu Wakaura Graduate
Ushio Tanaka Graduate
Akiko Kutsuna part-time assistant
1.3 Terms of Reference
(1) Academic Contribution in terms of
(a) Statistical methods: Outcome and Impact
(b) Seismology: Outcome and Impact
(c) Cooperative Research Activities
(2) Contribution to the Society
(3) Bring up Next Generation
(4) Prospect of Future Development and Suggestions
The Review Committee visited the
The main body of the Report is divided into sections following broadly the sequence set out in the terms of reference.
2. Members of the Committee would like to express their appreciation to Professor Kitagawa for the opportunity to participate in the Review, and to Professor Kitagawa, to members of the Institute's administrative staff, and to members of the Statistical Seismology Research Group, for the many courtesies extended to them during their visit. They would also like to express their appreciation of the care and thoroughness with which the review materials had been prepared for them before the Review took place.
Quality and impact of academic activities
3. The work the Review Committee was asked to consider comprised papers published in the period 2003-2005, or in publication; contributions to conference proceedings over a similar period; and material presented to the Committee at the time of the Review. The material is summarized in Appendix 2. We consider the work separately from statistical and seismological viewpoints, with a short overview at the end of the section.
Statistical theory and methodology
4. The work of the Statistical Seismology Group is highly regarded within the statistical community, especially within the areas of spatial statistics and point processes. Their work provides a vivid illustration of how the demands of a particular field can trigger the development of new statistical approaches. In seismology, the extensive, high-quality earthquake catalogues which started to become available two or three decades ago in Japan and elsewhere, characterized as they are by high-dimensionality, power law dependencies, extensive clustering, and near self-similarity, raise problems which lie outside the framework of conventional statistical techniques, and require the development of new models and new methods for their effective analysis. Professor Ogata and his colleagues have made, and are making, fundamental contributions towards overcoming these problems. As similar data become available in other fields - finance, medicine, population studies, and many others - the importance of the Group's work may increase, provided it can be communicated effectively to workers in these fields. Their work is also an outstanding demonstration of the value statistical methods can have in assisting the development of an observational discipline, and a tribute to the Group's ability to work alongside their seismologist colleagues.
5. Professor Ogata's papers have appeared in major general journals such as the Journal of the American Statistical Association, Biometrika and the Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, as well as in specialist journals and conference proceedings in point processes and spatial statistics. The extensive series of invitations he receives to international statistics meetings provide further evidence of his personal high standing. During the last few years he has been ably supported by Dr. Zhuang, but the more recent members of the Group strengthen the seismological rather than the statistical side of the work. Overall, and as the work of the Group expands, there is some danger of putting an over large burden on Professor Ogata's shoulders, requiring him to develop new, cutting edge ideas in statistics, to illustrate the effectiveness of these ideas within seismology and elsewhere, and to maintain the general oversight and management of the Group. In this respect the Group's overall position would be strengthened by the addition of a senior colleague on the statistical as well as on the seismological side.
6. Three aspects of the work under review may be singled out as topics to which the Group has made especially important contributions: the development of procedures for estimating the parameters of non-homogenous, rapidly evolving, space-time point processes (,); the development of stochastic declustering algorithms for separating clustered point data into clustering and background components (,); and the development of residual analysis methods for investigating discrepancies in the fit of time and space-time point process models (,,). The methods were developed in the first instance around versions of the ETAS (epidemic type aftershock sequence) models, but they are capable of extension to wider classes of models and many different contexts. For example, the stochastic declustering approach has potential value in many situations where spatial clusters are developed over time, while the Group's work on residual methods includes both pioneering contributions and important recent contributions to a major focus of current interest in spatial statistics.
7. In all three aspects mentioned the work of the group is outstanding and establishes it as one of the leading groups worldwide developing practical statistical methods for handling higher dimensional point process problems. They have produced useful results also in other directions, for example in handling renewal models with errors in variables, and in point process data controlled by a combination of endogenous (clustering) and exogeneous (external predictor) variables. A second round of challenges from seismology may be expected in the near future, as the extensive data on earth deformation from GPS and other satellite measurements builds up, and invites analysis both in its own right, and in conjunction with the seismicity data. The Institute, and the Statistical Seismology Group in particular, is strategically placed to play a prominent role in tackling these challenges.
1.4 Seismological theory and methodology
8. The ISM Statistical Seismology Group is recognized worldwide as one of the most active, productive and innovative research groups in modelling the evolution of seismicity in space and time. Despite the small number of researchers, the number of research publications from the Group is rather high. The publication list of the four core members of the group contains more than 32 publications in the period 2003-2005, even though some of the postdocs joined the group only in 2004 or late 2005. Continuation of the present high quality level of the activity is attested by the number of papers submitted or in press. The journals where research papers from the group are usually published are of high international standing, suitable for the research tasks, and effective in publicizing their scientific results and promoting collaboration with other research groups in geophysics.
9. From the seismological point of view, the topics listed as goals or motivations in the Group's report are extremely important and focus on high priority topics that attract the attention and the research of many groups within the international seismological community. The goals are also robust, and of relevance for promoting advanced studies in related fields; they can be shared by many investigators in geophysics.
In particular, their contributions to the analysis of the space-time evolution
of seismicity are excellent. This group has developed efficient models and
numerical tools that allow remarkably important practical applications to
analyze seismic activity both retrospectively and in real time. Among them the
most important is the ETAS model, which represents a powerful tool for
investigating the seismicity pattern, identifying the background seismicity and
its spatial distribution, determining the rate of production of aftershocks and
foreshocks, and modelling seismicity rate changes in space and time. The ETAS
model is now used in different regions of the world (
11. One important outcome emerging from these studies is the use of statistical models as diagnostic tools to identify anomalous trends and other features of the seismicity pattern. The ETAS model itself is an extremely useful tool in detecting anomalous features in seismic activity, including aftershock activity, and in identifying and defining seismic quiescence. The results of comparing the actual seismicity rates with the rates predicted by the ETAS model have very interesting implications for the physical interpretation of the processes controlling the evolution of seismicity. The connections between seismicity rate changes and coseismic stress changes have been emphasized by the ISM group and discussed in several important recent publications. In particular, it is worth noting that the relative quiescence defined in relation to the ETAS model represents the best currently available definition and physical interpretation of the gstress shadowh. In other words, this represents the most robust definition the stress shadow and the proposed numerical approach is the best solution to identify seismicity rate reductions. This has been recognized by the scientific community.
12. The Group has a good record in opening up new ideas. For instance, the physical interpretation of their results on the seismicity evolution in terms of stress perturbations caused by earthquakes is extremely important and of relevance for many researchers in seismology and geophysics. The Review Committee also appreciates the value of linking Toda to the Group, where he has already contributed significantly through his expertise on Coulomb stress modelling and the theoretical predictions of seismicity rate changes with physical models based on laboratory derived friction laws. For instance, the possibility now being explored by the Group of selecting target areas for statistical analysis by reference to the pattern of Coulomb stress changes is very interesting.
13. The success of the Group and the recognition of its work by leading members in the international community are quite evident, as was effectively demonstrated by the successful STATSEI-4 workshop recently organized by Ogata. All members of the Review Committee participated in the workshop and had a useful opportunity to gauge the impressions of participants, as well as to see presentations by the younger researchers in the group. It is the Committee's view that the Group has a large impact within the scientific community, and is leading the field into new directions.
14. The work done by the younger researchers is good and promises well for the future. Zhuang in particular has contributed significantly to the development of new approaches and is well integrated into the Group's research work. The most recent postdocs are promising, enthusiastic and well-motivated. They come to the Group with their own fields of research, which then have to be integrated within the Group's strategic working plans. For instance, Iwata's studies on tidal triggering appear robust statistically, but problems remain with the physical interpretation. At present the studies seem somewhat academic, although the study of triggering mechanisms is extremely important; a promising direction for further work might be to join the ETAS model with the Dieterich model with arbitrary stressing rates. Nanjo's work on earthquake prediction seems to lie a little outside the main strategic working plan of the Group, although it might be interesting to perform a systematic comparison between the PI and the ETAS approaches. Overall, the Review Committee hopes that further new students and postdocs can join the Group and contribute to the opening up of new ideas and horizons (time-dependent seismic hazard, for instance).
The Group's participation in and collaboration with the Earth Simulator was
outlined by R. Matsufura in a presentation to the Committee. It is interesting,
stimulating, and should be further implemented and maintained in the
future. It raises the wider issues,
taken up in more detail later in the Report, of how the ISM Group can most usefully
collaborate with other groups in
2 Cooperative research activities and contributions to the public good.
The Group enjoys productive collaborations with leading statisticians and
seismologists both within
2.1 Interinstitute activities
The Group has been collaborating for many years with leading statisticians and
seismologists internationally, such as Professor Vere-Jones (
The Fourth Statistical Seismology Workshop preceding the Review provided
extremely valuable opportunities for interinstitute collaborations. The Group
invited Prof. Dieterich for tutorial presentations on the fault constitutive
law, implying forthcoming very fruitful collaboration of the Group with him and
colleagues on modeling seismicity on the basis of the fault behavior. More than
65 researchers from various organizations in many regions and countries, such
as China, France, Germany, Italy, Mexico, New Zealand, Switzerland, Taiwan, UK,
and USA as well as Japan attended the three-full-day meeting and one-day
excursion. Talks presented at the meeting invited the Group to collaborate with
on-going or planned real-time testing of various seismicity models. Dr. Wiemer
introduced a European framework for testing earthquake forecast models and Dr.
Schorlemmer summarized the initial effort of the Regional Earthquake Likelihood
Models (RELM) project for testing various earthquake potential models in
19. The Group as such is not connected through formal collaborative agreements with other research groups, although in the past the Institute as a whole has had formal collaborative agreements which promoted the work in statistical seismology, for example with Victoria University in New Zealand. At present the Group rather informally collaborates with key and influential international research groups as was exemplified by the successful Statsei Workshop. If any formal research agreement is considered, the Institute should provide strong administrative support.
2.2 Contributions to the public good
Prof. Ogata is an active member of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake
Prediction, which meets every three months for discussion and exchange of ideas
and information on the latest seismic and crustal activity in
22. Probabilistic forecasts of aftershocks are issued by JMA and ERC after an occurrence of large earthquakes. Although the forecast is based on the Omori-Utsu formula and not on the ETAS model, both JMA and ERC adopt the maximum likelihood estimation of parameters developed by Prof. Ogata. ERC (2005) made public the 'Generalized National Seismic Hazard Maps' and plans to revise it in five years. The maps utilize probabilistic estimates of an occurrence of large earthquakes, which are mainly based on a renewal model of earthquake recurrence. For the revision, the uncertainty in the probabilistic estimates will be discussed and Prof. Ogata's statistical work on processing paleoearthquake data will be a useful guide to future directions.
It is clear that members of the Group would be welcome as participants in
international projects involving real time tests and validation tests such as
3 Bringing up the next generation
The Review Committee is satisfied that a high quality of training is being offered
to the graduate students and post-docs associated with the Group, but
disappointed that the numbers are still small. It appears to the Committee that
there is only a limited number of young researchers in statistical seismology,
25. The Committee notes that the ISM provides an annual open seminar to the public or young scientists. Any such seminar needs to be considered an important opportunity to publicize the activity of this Group. Coordination among the research groups in ISM is necessary, but in general the Committee recommends that the ISM, and the Statistical Seismology Group in particular, take every opportunity to impress on young scientists the Group's achievements and their significance in earthquake science.
26. Every spring and autumn, the Seismological Society of Japan (hereafter SSJ) holds its annual meetings. On average more than 500 papers on several aspects of earthquake science will be presented. Therefore it is not so easy for statistical seismology to be highlighted in the meeting. However the group can use other mechanisms provided by SSJ for this purpose. In particular, SSJ holds a Summer School on Seismology every summer, which is aimed exclusively at young students such as undergraduate students or master course students in graduate school. The theme of the summer school is selected from proposals or requests of SSJ members. Other societies may also have similar seminars. The Statistical Seismology Group could ask SSJ and other societies to periodically choose statistical seismology as the theme of the seminar. The participation of the Group in such activities would need to be supported by the Institute.
27. The credit exchange program with the Soken-dai and other universities could be used to attract the interests of young students. The best way might be to run lecture series for the students from other universities which have credit exchange programs. ISM is a part of the Soken-dai and they have a course of statistics including statistical seismology. Unfortunately there are very few lecture series on statistical seismology in Japanese universities at the present time. The main reason is the lack of experts in this field. University visiting professor or temporary lecturer positions can also offer useful opportunities to have lectures in other universities. The Group should consider the use of such programs.
4 Comments and suggestions for the future work plan
The Statistical Seismology Group within the ISM occupies a unique position, not
The goals of seismological research are as varied as the reasons society is
willing to invest in them, ranging from the purely academic to the highly
applied. The questions that society
commonly asks earthquake professionals are typically something like "when
will the next earthquake strike?", "how severe will it be?" or
"what can be done to lessen its impact?" Precise answers to these questions are
currently beyond our grasp, and may always be so. Within the seismological, earthquake
engineering and emergency management communities, however, the value of even
approximate answers to such questions is widely recognized. The new long-term earthquake forecast
Within the framework of the Group's current research program, the Review
Committee particularly encourages the development of collaborative work with
researchers in other fields to incorporate deeper physical modeling into the
statistical analysis. As a primary example, it is important to deepen the
understanding of the statistical characteristics of seismicity in relation to
the physical processes taking place in the earth. Statistical seismology tends to treat
earthquakes as just a sample from a random process, while observational
seismology tends to focus on the characteristics of individual
earthquakes. Both approaches are
important, but statistical seismology has not won major popularity in
earthquake science, especially in
The Review Committee also strongly encourages further development of the
program to rigorously evaluate models and forecasts. The hierarchical space-time modeling of
seismicity (HIST) holds great promise, and clearly represents frontier research
at the leading edge of the field. As one example, the Coulomb failure stress
model appears to be ripe for a carefully designed validation experiment, given
the new information--rich earthquake catalogs available in
Beyond this, the
Statistical models of seismicity are already being applied in public policy
decision analysis in
To highlight one particular example where the ISM might be able to contribute,
for society, it is the shaking of the ground that matters far more than the
rupture of the fault. The predicted
intensity of ground motion controls the seismic design requirements for
structures of all kinds. Trillions
of Yen are invested every year in
5 Overall conclusions and recommendations
35. The Review Committee has no doubts about the high academic quality and scientific value of the work being done by the Statistical Seismology Group. The Group has initiated and carried through important developments as much from the seismological as from the statistical side. Its members, and Professor Ogata in particular, are highly respected in both communities for their innovative approach to problems of modelling and analysis of seismological data, their insights, and their ability to develop their work in collaboration with professional scientists in both fields. Their work should continue to be strongly supported and promoted.
The Committee was also very interested to learn about the scope of the work
undertaken by the Institute, and impressed by both its breadth and depth. Many problems of critical importance to
society are being investigated in partnership with leading experts from allied
fields. The Committee was
particularly interested to learn of the programs in risk evaluation and risk
management. The work in financial
and environmental risk represents important contributions to informed decision
making in an increasingly complex and interconnected global economy. It seems only natural that a
complementary program of research on earthquake risk would also pay a high
return on investment to society. No
country has a larger percentage of its population or national wealth at risk
from earthquakes than
37. Greater difficulties present themselves in regard to the expansion of the Group and its ability to attract and train top quality graduate students. The Review Committee sees good work being done by students and post-docs, but the Group is not training sufficient numbers in this increasingly important area. At the same time there is a need for a senior staff member, particularly now on the statistical side, to assist Professor Ogata in the development of new statistical modelling and methodology and in further development of the program to rigorously evaluate models.
38. The Review Committee recommends that these issues be given serious consideration by the ISM management, not just in the context of the Statistical Seismology Group itself, but also in the wider context of the ISM's involvement with engineering, insurance, and risk management.
 Ogata, Y.(1988) Statistical Models for earthquake occurrence and residual analysis for point processes. Journal of the American Statistical Association. 83, 9-27.
 Ogata Y., Katsura, K., and Tanemura, M (2003) Modelling of heterogeneous space-time seismic activity and its residual analysis Appl. Stat (Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C). 52, 499-509.
 Ogata, Y. and Zhuang, J. (2006) Space-time ETAS models and an improved extension. Tectonophysics 413, 13-23.
 Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2004) Stochastic declustering of space-time earthquake occurrences. Journal of the American Statistical Association 97, 369-380.
 Zhuang, J. (2006) Second-order residual analysis of spatiotemporal point processes and applications in model evaluation, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 67, 68, Part4, 635-653
Appendix 1: Schedule of External Review
Place: Meeting Room of the Institute of statistical Mathematics
Date: January 16, 2006
10:00 – 10:10 Introduction by Genshiro Kitagawa (Director General)
* Objective of evaluation
* Terms of reference
10:10 – 10:20 Preliminary meeting
* Selection of chairperson
* Schedule and method
10:20 – 10:40 Hearing from Dr. Matsufura
10:40 – 11:40 Report by Prof. Ogata
11:40 – 12:20 Report by group members
13:30 – 13:50 Report by group members
13:50 – 15:00 Questions and discussion
15:30 – 17:10 Meeting
* Arrangement for making review report
17:10 – 17:30 Comments by review committee
Date: January 17, 2006
10:00 – 12:00 Meeting
* Arrangement for making review report
Appendix 2: Summary of materials presented to the Review Committee
(Notes: Page numbers of the table of contents are those paginated for original report presented to the Committee)
Research Organization of Information and Systems
Motivations behind this project cccccccccccccccccccccccc 2
@(1) Hypocenter data cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 2
@(2) Other geophysical datasets ccccccccccccccccccccccccc... ccc 2
(3) Point-process models ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 2
@(4) Earthquake / Aftershock forecasting ccccccccccccccccccccccccc 3
@(5) Exploration and modeling of the interface between physical and stochastic processes c..ccc 4
@(6) Space-time point-process modeling cccccccccccccccccccccc.ccc 5
@References ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc.ccccc 5
Objectives of the project ccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 7
Work Plan 2003 – 2007 ccccccccccccccccccccccc.. cccc 8
Project Members cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 8
Research Accomplishments 2003 – 2005 ccccccccccccccccccc..c 9
@Principal works during 2003 – 2005 cccccccccccccccccccccccc 9
(1) Coseismic activation / quiescence triggered by a large earthquake and Coulomb stress changes ccccc 9
(2) Relative quiescence in aftershock sequences and its mechanism ccccccccccccccccc 10
(3) Seismicity anomalies preceding large earthquakes and crustal stress changes cccccccccccc 11
(4) Space-time ETAS modeling cccccccccccccccccccccccccc..c. ccc 13
(5) Modeling the interface between physical and stochastic process ccccccccccccccc... 15
(6) Simultaneous estimation of b-values and detection rates of earthquakes for the application to aftershock
probability forecasting ccccccccccccccccccccccccc..ccccccc. 16
Published papers 2003 – 2005 ccccccccccccccccccccc.c.cc.ccc 16
Refereed Journals ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc..cccc. 16
Main Proceedings cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 18
Future plans for the project cccccccccccccccccccccccc.. 20
(1) Examination of scenarios for predicting asperity-slip based on the seismicity anomalies cc.. ccc.. 20
(2) Effective space-time modeling of seismic activity and detection of seismicity anomalies ccccc.c.. 21
(3) Predictive space-time-magnitude characterization of foreshocks ccccccccccccccc..c 21
(4) Prediction and inversion problem between seismicity changes and stress-changes ccccccc.cc. 22
(5) Bayesian Probability assessments for Long-term prediction cccccccccc.ccccccc 22
(6) Statistical modeling for more effective use and quality improvements of datasets cccccccc... 23
References cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc 23
The Hypocenter catalog
of the Japan
Meteorological Agency (JMA) is one of the most valuable
databases for earthquake prediction. This is because it contains records of a
large number of earthquakes dating back to 1925. The catalog covers the whole
There are many precise geophysical records that are
useful in discussing the relationship with seismicity such as records of
extensometers, tiltmeters, volmetric strainmeters and the GPS. However, these
records are usually affected by various noises or ancillary geophysical signals
caused by the earthtides, and in particular, by meteorological factors
such as barometric pressure, precipitation, temperature and humidity.
Therefore, it is important to model the causal relationships and response
functions of these effects in order to calibrate the records for genuine
quantities of interest. For example, the computer program BAYTAP-G [Ishiguro
et al., 1984] used to implement the Bayesian deconvolution procedure for removing
tidal effects has been used with much
frequency by many researchers in seismology and geodesy in
Point processes. A point-process is a mathematical model of the stochastic occurrence of a series of events. The modeling of point-processes became a powerful tool in the field of applied statistics in the 1980fs, for three reasons. Firstly, the concept of the conditional intensity function provided us with an extensive free hand with which to produce models describing the detailed interface between the physical mechanism of occurrences and some stochastic factors. This is the predictive occurrence rate function (roughly, the differential of the occurrence conditional probability) of the present time, the occurrence times of the past events and other relevant time series data such as magnitudes and other available geophysical records. Use of this function also made available a general effective simulation method using the thinning operation [Ogata, 1983]. Secondly, it became possible to write the likelihood function directly in terms of the conditional intensity function. The third reason was due to the availability of practical algorithms for optimizing non-linear functions using a computer, enabling us to obtain the maximum likelihood estimate (MLE), their error estimates, and the likelihood-ratio or the AIC to examine the goodness-of-fit of models. Together with these revolutionary bases, a diagnostic analysis of the model and data became available with the time-transformation using the integral of the conditional intensity function [Ogata, 1983, 1988; Ogata and Shimazaki, 1984; Ogata, 1999]. Benefiting from these, a substantial number of applications became available, including the program packages TIMSAC84 [Akaike et al., 1985] and SASeis [Utsu and Ogata, 1997] in the IASPEI Software Library.
The ETAS model. The epidemic type aftershock sequence (ETAS) model [Ogata, 1986, 1988, 1989] is one such model. It is generally accepted that each earthquake changes the probability of successive earthquakes in a region, the size of which scales with its magnitude, and by an amount that can be estimated using the Gutenberg-Richter magnitude distribution and the Omori-Utsu law for the rate of aftershocks, where aftershocks are allowed to be larger than the mainshock. The ETAS model forms the basis of many current probabilistic earthquake prediction schemes. Inherent in these models is the assumption that the probability of a large earthquake is completely determined by the sum of stresses transferred by prior earthquakes within a considered region. By a set of parameter values the ETAS model is well adapted to various seismicity patterns including the mainshock-aftershock type and swarm type.
Diagnostic analysis using the ETAS model. Since a sequence of aftershocks is triggered by complex mechanisms under fractal random media, it is difficult to calculate the transferred stresses within and near the rupture fault. That is, triggering mechanics within an aftershock sequence are too complex for us to calculate the effect of stress changes. Therefore, the statistical empirical laws of aftershocks are useful as a practical representation of the outcome due to the complex interaction of the self- or proximate triggering. On the other hand, the ETAS model is a statistical model constructed based on the empirical laws of aftershocks. Therefore, the model itself hardly describes the mechanism of affecting stress changes behind the seismicity changes. Diagnostic analyses of the model can reveal such new knowledge included in the data. That is to say, the activation and quiescence relative to the modelfs prediction could suggest exogenous stress-changes in the regions.
Primary models for aftershock forecasting. It has been about a decade since aftershock probability forecasting
[Reasenberg and Jones, 1989] was
implemented to inform the public in
Anomalous aftershock activity. Precursory seismic quiescence as a predictor of large earthquakes has attracted much attention amongst seismologists in the last several decades, ever since Inouye  first proposed the concept. This suggests that we need much more research into the relation between the quiescence and subsequent earthquake activity in order to obtain an effective prediction. We should also explain how quiescence can take place in a much wider area than the rupture source [Inouye, 1965; Ogata, 1992]. Studying many aftershock sequences should provide us with a better understanding of the physical mechanism of the precursory utility. For predicting large aftershock, Matsufura  noted the utility of the quiescence in aftershock occurrences relative to the Omori-Utsu decaying formula.
Using the ETAS model and on the basis of the proposed procedure, 259 aftershock sequences of various threshold magnitudes are investigated for the 76 main shocks of M6 class or over that occurred in and around Japan during the last three-quarters of the last century [Ogata, 2001]. Relative quiescence is revealed in ~40% of the aftershock sequences, and almost all of the others are developed normally; relative activation is rarely found. We have seen that the aftershock activity provides useful information for assessing the probability of a following large event (M6 class or over) in the neighbourhood. Namely, if the aftershock activity from the first event becomes relatively quiet compared to the expected normal decay, the occurrence rate of a larger event in the neighbourhood (within a distance of 3o) is a few times higher during the first decade after the main shock than would be the case for normal aftershock activity. However, it is not yet clearly understood the physical mechanism of the causal relationship between the relative quiescence and the forthcoming occurrences of large aftershocks or even large earthquakes of the similar size to the mainshock. The recently accumulated earthquake mechanism data may help better our understanding.
Seismicity rate change and Coulombfs failure stress change. We are concerned with the precise prediction of time- and history-dependent occurrence rates of an earthquake sequence, particularly, aftershock sequences, in order to test the hypothesis that abrupt stress-change due to a seismic or an aseismic slip triggers a seismicity-rate-change in the surrounding area. This is because stress changes in a region are very frequently affected by nearby events, which trigger further aftershock clusters. In principle, seismic activity should be enhanced in the zones where an increment of Coulombfs failure stress (CFS) is positive, and also activity should be reduced (seismic quiescence) in the stress-shadow zones. For example, some retrospective case studies have shown the stress shadow [e.g., Harris, 1998; Toda and Stein, 2002] due to large earthquakes to coseismically inhibit the activity in some neighboring seismic regions in California, in addition to many cases of activated seismicity triggered by an large event [e.g., Toda et al., 1998]. A similar phenomena can be expected by the activation and quiescence relative to the predicted seismicity by the ETAS model.
External stress changes and swarms. It is well known that volcanic swarms and other swarms are affected by magma intrusion [Dieterich et al., 2000; Toda et al., 2002] and water migration [Matsufura and Karakama, 2005]. According to the Coulomb failure criterion, the variation of both, stress and pore pressure, can result in earthquake rupture. Aftershock sequences characterized by the Omori-Utsu law are often assumed to be the consequence of varying stress, whereas earthquake swarms are supposed to be triggered by fluid intrusions. Statistical models for describing the relationship are desired. Also, there are some papers reporting that occurrence rates of some swarms and aftershocks are correlated to certain components of earth-tidefs time series [e.g., Iwata, 2002]. It is desirable to have models examining the causal relationship between mechanisms of earthquakes and stress tensors of stresses due to earth-tide.
Inversion. On the other hand, it will be informative to produce an image of the geophysical quantities in time and space, by making an inversion of the parameters of the statistical models of earthquake occurrences. Such examples include b-values of the G-R magnitude frequency [Ogata et al. 1993a and b], and p-values of the Omori-Utsu model for the aftershock decay [Mogi, 1967]. More examples should also be considered, making use of models such as the extended space-time ETAS model, making use of a Bayesian framework. The geophysical quantities could include the stress distribution and temperatures of the crust, and the friction coefficients of the fault interface (asperities) etc.
Quiescence and activation relative to the ETAS prediction and crustal stress changes. Seismic quiescence and activation have attracted much attention amongst seismologists as the precursors to a large earthquake. Of particular interest is that the stress-changes transferred from a far-field rupture or silent slip can cause seismic changes in a region. On the other hand, since a sequence of aftershocks is triggered by complex mechanisms under heterogeneous fractal media, it is difficult to precisely describe the transfer of stresses both within and near to the field. In other words, triggering mechanics within an aftershock sequence are too complex to calculate the effect of stress changes. Nevertheless, we can use statistical empirical laws as a practical solution to aftershock triggering. That is to say, fitting and extrapolating a suitable statistical model for normal seismic activity in a situation without exogenous stress changes provides us with an alternative method through which to see the seismicity changes explicitly. Thus, our motivation is to show the possibility that the diagnostic analysis based on fitting the ETAS model, and its space-time extension, fitting to regional seismicity can be helpful in detecting small exogenous stress changes. Indeed, these changes are so slight that the geodetic records from the GPS network can barely recognize systematic anomalies in the time series of displacement records.
quiescence before great earthquakes is discussed in wide seismic regions in Ogata  for high threshold
magnitudes of more than M5. However, these are too high to discuss intermediate
strong earthquakes. The locations of earthquakes from hypocenter catalogs are
now accurate enough to discuss the spatial aspect of seismicity, such as the
clustering of aftershocks and seismicity gaps. Ogata  considers several possible extensions of the ETAS
model to space-time data, based on classical empirical studies of aftershocks,
and also on a number of contrasting speculative hypotheses about the physical
nature of the space-time clustering. Their goodness-of-fit is compared by the
aid of the AIC for two data sets from tectonically distinctive areas in and
However, as the data size increases, spatial heterogeneity of the seismic activity becomes conspicuous. For example, shape of the anistropic clustering becomes more complex, differing from place to place. Even cluster sizes are significantly different from one another, especially between those in offshore and inland area [Utsu, 1969; Ogata, 2001].
Furthermore, according to the restricted trigger model [Ogata, 2001], secondary aftershocks of large cluster sizes are
located around the boundary of the main rupture zone of the 1995
Ozaki, T., Ishiguro, M., Ogata, Y., Kitagawa, G., Tamura, Y., Arahata, E.,
Katsura, K. and Tamura, R. (1985) Time Series and Control Program Package,
TIMSAC-84 (, Computer Science Monograph, No. 22/23, The Institute of
Aki, K. (1965)
Maximum likelihood estimate of b in the formula log N = a-bM and its confidence limits, Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst., Univ.
Cayol, V. and Okubo, P., The use of earthquake rate changes as a stress meter
Guo, Z. and Ogata, Y. (1997) Statistical relations between the parameters of aftershocks in time, space and magnitude, Journal Geophysical Research, Vol. 102, No. B2, pp. 2857-2873.
Harris, R. A. (1998) Introduction to special section: Stress triggers, stress shadows, and implications for seismic hazard, J. Geophys. Res., 103, 24,347–24,358.
Inouye, W. (1965) On the
seismicity in the epicentral region and its neighborhood before the
Ishiguro, M., Akaike, H., Ooe, M.
and Nakai, S. (1981). A Bayesian approach to the analysis of earth tide, Proceedings of the 9th International
Simposium on Earth Tides, (ed. J.T. Kuo), E. Schweizerbart'sche
Iwata, T. (2002) Tidal
stress/strain and acoustic emission activity at the underground research
Kitagawa, G. and Matsumoto, N. (1996). Detection of coseismic changes of underground water level, J. Amer. Stats. Assoc., 91, 521-528.
Matsu'ura R.S. (1986) Precursory
quiescence and recovery of aftershock activities before some large aftershocks,
Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst., Univ.
Matsu'ura R.S., Hirata, N. and Urabe, S. (1995) Quasi-real-time watch of the aftershock activity change of Hyogoken-nanbu Earthquake – Prediction of Jan. 23 23h 16m M4.7 aftershock (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 54, pp. 600-607.
Matsu'ura R.S. and
Mogi, K. (1967) Earthquakes and fractures, Tectonophysics, 5, 35-55.
Ogata, Y. (1978) The asymptotic behavior of maximum likelihood estimators for stationary point processes, Annals of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics, Vol. 30, No. 2, A, pp. 243-261.
Ogata, Y. (1981) On Lewis' simulation method for point processes, IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, Vol. IT-27, pp. 23-31.
Ogata, Y. (1983) Estimation of the parameters in the modified Omori formula for aftershock frequencies by the maximum likelihood procedure, Journal of Physics of the Earth, Vol. 31, pp. 115-124.
Ogata, Y. and Shimazaki, K. (1984) Transition from aftershock to normal activity, Bull. Seismo. Soc. Am., 74, 5, pp. 1757-1765.
(1986) Statistical models for earthquake occurrences and residual analysis for
point processes, Mathematical Seismology (I),
Ogata, Y. (1988) Statistical models for earthquake occurrences and residual analysis for point processes, Journal of American Statistical Association, Application, Vol. 83, No. 401, pp. 9-27.
Ogata, Y. (1989) Statistical model for standard seismicity and detection of anomalies by residual analysis, Techtonophysics, Vol. 169, pp. 159-174.
Ogata, Y. (1992) Detection of precursory relative quiescence before great earthquakes through a statistical model, J. Geophys. Res., 97, 19845-19871.
Ogata, Y. (1998) Space-time point-process models for earthquake occurrences, Ann. Inst. Statist. Math., 50, 379-402.
(1999) Seismicity analyses through point-process modelling: A review, in
Seismicity Patterns, Their Statistical Significance and Physical Meaning M. Wyss,
K. Shimazaki and A. Ito eds. Birkhauser Verlag,
Ogata, Y. (2001) Exploratory analysis of earthquake clusters by likelihood-based trigger models, Festscrift Volume for Professor Vere-Jones, J. Applied Probability, 38A, pp. 202-212.
Ogata, Y., Imoto, M. and Katsura, K. (1993a) 3-D spatial variation of b-values of magnitude-frequency distribution beneath the Kanto District, Japan, Geophys. J. Int., 113, 727-738.
Ogata, Y. and Katsura, K. (1993b) Analysis of temporal and spatial heterogeneity of magnitude frequency distribution inferred from earthquake catalogs, Geophys. J. Int., 113, pp. 727-738.
Ogata, Y. and Zhuang. J. (2001)
Statistical examination of anomalies for the precursor to earthquakes, and the
multi-element precision formula: hazard rate changes of strong earthquakes
F. On the aftershocks of earthquakes, J.
Coll. Sci. Imp. Univ.
Reasenberg, P.A. and Jones, L.M. (1989)
Earthquake hazard after a mainshock in
Toda, S. Stein, R.S., Reasenberg P.A. and Dieterich
J.H. and Yoshida, A. (1998) Stress transferred by the Mw=6.9
Toda, S. and Stein, R.S. (2002) Response of the
Toda, S., Stein, R.S. and Sagiya, T., (2002) Evidence from the AD 2000 Izu Islands swarm that stressing rate governs seismicity, Nature, 419, pp. 58-61, 5 September issue.
Utsu, T., A statistical study on the occurrence of aftershocks, Geophys. Mag., 30, 521605, 1961.
Utsu, T. (1965) A method for determinig the value of b in a formula log n = bM showing the magnitude- frequency relation for earthquakes, Geophys Bull Hokkaido Univ., 13, 99-103 (in Japanese).
Utsu,T. (1969).Aftershocks and earthquake statistics(I): some parameters which characterize an aftershock sequence and their interaction, Journal of the Faculty of Science, Hokkaido University, Ser. VII (geophysics), 3, 129-195.
Utsu, T., Ogata, Y. and Matsu'ura, R. S. (1995) The centenary of the Omori formula for a decay law of aftershock activity, J. Phys. Earth, 43, 1-33.
Utsu, T. and Ogata, Y. (1997) Computer program package: Statistical Analysis of point processes for Seismicity (SASeis), invited and accepted for IASPEI Software Library for Personal Computers, the International Association of Seismology and Physics of Earth's Interior, vol. 6, 13-94.
Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2002). Stochastic declustering of space-time earthquake occurrences, J. Amer. Statist. Assoc., 97, 369-380.
(1) To develop practical space-time models that are sufficiently close to the real seismic activity. Specifically, the model must elaborate enough to spatially adapt to various different clustering patterns. In order to represent various seismicity patterns, we will adopt a hierarchical space-time point-process model, in which the parameter values are dependent on the location of the earthquakes.
(2) To detect and evaluate anomalous features of general seismicity and aftershock activity relative to the modeled rate by the ETAS model, to explore its space-time features using statistical diagnostic methods and to make modeling of seismicity anomalies.
(3) To explore the relation between the seismicity-rate-change in a region and the stress-change in the crust, which varies due to the fault mechanisms of earthquakes.
(4) To statistically model the relationship between the occurrence time series of focal earthquakes in a region and the time series records of anomaly events, in order to enhance the performance of probability forecasting.
(5) To model the heterogeneity of various datasets which are affected by some instrumental and geophysical factors, such as various noises, missing events or values, and detection rate changes of earthquakes in time and space.
We will undertake as many of the followings as early as possible:
(1) We will apply the ETAS model to a number of sequences of earthquakes from various regions over a recent period to examine any significant deviation of the activity from the rate predicted by the model. We will explore matching such an anomaly and a crustal stress-change due to a co-seismic and a pre-seismic slip somewhere in order to examine whether such a seismic anomaly can be a sensitive sensor of stress change.
(2) We will particularly be concerned with the anomalously quiet aftershock activity preceding a large aftershock.
(3) We will make use of fault mechanism data of earthquakes to calculate the Coulomb-stress-change estimation transferred from a pre-slip or a slow slip in order to discuss the significance of the causal relation between stress change and seismicity anomalies.
(4) We will try to make a statistical point process model to explain the causality between geodetic anomalies and seismicity anomalies in the same field.
(5) We will publish a software package to make programs available such as the estimation and diagnostic procedure of the ETAS model for the seismologists, after testing the stability of such programs.
(6) We will make a practical model to enable real-time probability forecasting of aftershocks immediately after a large earthquake (say, within 24hours), when the detection rate of aftershocks is extremely low, due to contamination of arriving seismic waves. This is urgent since the majority of large aftershocks are most likely to occur during this period, and hence forecasting during this time is most critical for public in the affected area.
(7) We will develop methods of diagnostic analysis for space-time seismicity data by introducing a space-time seismicity-ratio of real seismicity to the predicted by the space-time ETAS model, and modeling it in Bayesian framework.
(8) We will prepare a software package to publish the MLE and Bayesian procedure of the space-time ETAS model, and test the stability of such programs with many datasets.
Statistical Seismology Research Group, Prediction and
OGATA, Prof. of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics (ISM)
Shinji TODA, Visiting Prof. of the ISM and Geological Survey of Japan, AIST, 2005 -
Yasuaki MURATA, Geological Survey of Japan, AIST , Visiting Assoc. Prof. of the ISM 2003 - 2004
Jiancang ZHUANG, Research Fellow upon JSPS program, 2001 - 2005
Kazuyoshi NANJO, Research Fellow upon JSPS program, 2003 -
Takaki IWATA, Research Fellow of ISM,
Masatsugu WAKAURA, Graduate Student, The
Ushio TANAKA, Graduate Student, The
Akiko KUTSUNA, part-time assistant
It is clearly seen that after a large earthquake, many off-fault activities with positive Coulomb stress increments are enhanced, while negative ones (stress shadow) are inhibited, in regions that include many earthquakes of similar fault-mechanisms detected down to small magnitudes. Such various examples are shown in western Japan, which was affected by the two great earthquakes of 1944 and 1946 in the Nankai trough, with other various ones being seen in Hokkaido inland and the southern offshore of Hokkaido which was affected by the 2003 Tokacho-Oki great earthquake. See also the published referred papers  , , , [A8], and the main reported manuscript [A15], [A16], [A23] and [A24] for further examples of coseismic triggering. These papers and reports are listed in the end of this section under Research Accomplishments.
Seismicity changes in western
stress-changes triggered by the 2003 Tokachi earthquake [A21, A33]. Coseismic activation and quiescence are
conspicuous in the eastern inland region of Hokkaido after the 2003 great
earthquake of M8.0 in the space-time occurrence of microearthquakes detected
from 2001 through 2003 (depth 25km).
The DCFF for the receiver faults
with N75oE right lateral strike-slip at the depth of 10km and the
Tokachi-Oki eventfs slip model takes positive and negative values in the
western and eastern part, respectively, which is corresponds well to the
regions of activation and quiescence in microseismicity. The exception is that
the very active spot in the western region suddenly stopped the activity after
the great event, but this is also well explained by the different alignment of
the receiver fault from the rest of the western part of the
microseismicity. We found another
triggered activation and quiescence in a complicated manner within the 3D
volume down to 100km depth beneath the southern inland region of
Coseismic activation and quiescence
relative to the ETAS model [22, A19].
Fitting and extrapolating the ETAS model for normal seismic activity in a
situation without exogenous stress changes provides us with an alternative
method through which we can detect the relative changes of seismicity
sensitively. Thus, the diagnostic analysis based on fitting the ETAS model is
helpful in detecting small exogenous stress changes. For example, shallow
earthquakes (M >=1.5) in the Tohoku inland region of largest DCFF values (ranging +5~+50 millibars) due
to the 2003 May 26 Miyagi-Ken-Oki earthquake of M7.1 is seen to be activated
relative to the predicted occurrence rate by the ETAS model. The foreshock
activity during the first event of M5.5 and the mainshock of M6.2 (the both
(2) Relative quiescence in aftershock sequences and its mechanism
In order to extract regional stress-changes transferred from
the slip of a far-field fault, we have to remove the effect of the complex,
proximate triggering mechanics occurring within
aftershock clusters. As a practical solution, the ETAS model is
fitted to the sequence of events from the region in order to precisely mimic the normal activity there. We
are primarily concerned with seismicity-rate-changes (enhancement and reduction)
relative to the rate predicted by the ETAS model, and explore matching them to
the pattern of Coulomb's stress-changes that occur due to a rupture or a
suspected silent slip. We have shown a number of such examples from recent
seismic activities in
Aftershock activity of large earthquakes in Southern California . The Hector Mine aftershock activity has been normal, relative to the decay predicted by the ETAS model during the 14 months of available data and no further large event has taken place in the vicinity up until now. In contrast, although the aftershock sequence of the 1992 Landers earthquake (M=7.3), including the 1992 Big Bear earthquake (M=6.4) and its aftershocks, fits very well to the ETAS up until about 6 months after the mainshock, the activity showed clear lowering relative to the modeled rate (relative quiescence) and the anomaly lasted nearly 7 years, leading up to the Hector Mine earthquake (M=7.1) in 1999. Specifically, the relative quiescence occurred only in the shallow aftershock activity, down to depths of 5 - 6 km. The sequence of deeper events showed clear, normal aftershock activity that fitted well to the ETAS throughout the whole period. We argue several physical explanations for these results. Among them, we strongly suspect aseismic slips within the Hector Mine rupture source that could inhibit the crustal relaxation process within gshadow zonesh of the Coulombfs failure stress change. Furthermore, the aftershock activity of the 1992 Joshua Tree earthquake (M=6.1) sharply lowered in the same day of the mainshock, which can be explained by a similar scenario due to aseismic slip.
Consecutive earthquakes in Miyagi
Prefecture and its offshore [22,
A19]. Anomalous seismicity such as quiescence and activation is
defined by a systematic deviation of seismic activity from the predicted rate
by the ETAS model that represents the normal occurrence-rate
of earthquakes in
a region indicating the empirical triggering effect by
the previous events.
The model is fitted to a dataset of origin-times and magnitudes of earthquakes or aftershocks
during May-August 2003 in and around northern
Anomalous aftershock activity of the 2004 Niigata-Ken-Chuetsu earthquake of M6.8 [A30]. We are concerned with the drastic shift of the depth distribution of aftershocks against time, around 0.5 days after the mainshock when we have no major aftershock. The cross-section of DCFF diagram for the aftershocks of similar mechanisms to the mainshockfs on the plane of faultfs strike direction of the mainshock (reverse faulting) against depth shows positive and negative values in shallow and deep parts of the aftershock volume, respectively, by the assumed precursory slip of the large M6.1 event that occurred 3.7 days after the mainshock. The precursory slip can be triggered by the mainshock rupture with a large positive DCFF.
Relative quiescence reported before the
occurrence of the largest aftershock (M5.8) with likely scenarios of precursory
slips considered for the stress-shadow covering the aftershock area [30, A27, A35]. Monitoring of aftershock
sequences to detect lowering activity, relative to the modeled rate (the
relative quiescence), becomes realistic and practical in predicting the
enhancement of the likelihood of having a substantially large aftershock, or
even another earthquake of similar size to the mainshock or larger. A
significant relative quiescence in the aftershock sequence of the 2005 March
earthquake of M7.0 off the western coast of
(3) Seismicity anomalies preceding large earthquakes and crustal stress changes
An earthquake prediction scenario from the implication of the relative quiescence can be based on the asperity hypothesis in the sense that precursory slip around asperities applies more shear stress to the asperities which promotes the rupture of the main fault. On the other hand, aseismic slips in a particular region are not necessarily a precursor to the large event but may be aseismic slips that are repeated in the same region with no subsequent large events. Therefore, identification of an aseismic slip leading to the rupture of an asperity remains a further difficult research theme in earthquake prediction. At present, this issue should be considered in terms of probabilistic prediction proactively making likely scenarios of precursory slips.
Intermediate-term seismicity anomalies preceding the rupture around the focal region of the 2004 Niigata-Ken-Chuetsu earthquake of M6.8 [A27, 29]. The ETAS model is applied to four sequences of earthquakes (M>=2), which occurred from 1997 through to October 2004 in four respective regions divided around the source of the 2004 Niigata-Ken Chuetsu earthquake. The four regions are divided North, East, South and East around the source by the boundaries of positive and negative CFS increments (i.e., the counters of neutral CFS increment) for the receiver faults (10km depth) of dominating angles in this region. The actual cumulative number of events deviates upward in region North and South, but downward in East and West, from the predicted cumulative curve after the change-point, consistently with the regions of the Coulomb increments. These show that precursory slip may have taken place in the Chuetsu mainshock fault plane.
Synchronous seismicity changes in and around the northern
Features of seismic activities in and around Tohoku District, northern Japan, prior to the large interplate earthquakes off the coast of Miyagi Prefecture [29, A20]. This paper is concerned with the intermediate-term prediction of the forthcoming M7.4 ~ 8.2 earthquake on the plate boundary, off the east coast of Miyagi Prefecture, northern Japan, which has the highest occurrence probability among the long-term forecasted events announced to the public. Seismicity and aftershocks in the regions of stress-shadow show significantly lower activity than the rate predicted by the ETAS model (the relative quiescence) during some years preceding each of the previous ruptures in 1936 and 1978, whereas the seismicity is normal or even activated in the regions of neutral or increasing Coulomb failure stress (CFS), which leads to the scenario based on the likely precursory slip within or near to the source.
such a scenario, a number of sequences of earthquakes or
aftershocks during 1979-2004 from various regions in northern
the aftershock sequences of the 2003 Tokachi-Oki earthquake of M8.0 and the
2004 Kushiro-Oki earthquake of M7.1, and seismicity changes in the eastern
Seismicity in and around the Kyushu
District, preceding the 2005 earthquake of M7.0 at the western offshore region
of Fukuoka Prefecture [A34]. The ETAS model is applied to the sequences of events with M1.5
during the 10 year period from1995 to
On distributions of focal mechanisms [12,
A11, A22, A25, A29].
see a change of the normalized frequency distribution of DCFS values before
and after 1995, calculated at the hypocenter of all earthquakes listed in the
JMA earthquake mechanisms catalog in a wide area of northern
we discussed the
likelihood of three rupture models of the 2005 earthquake of M7.4 off the coast
Stochastc clustering / declustering by the space-time ETAS model [13, 25, 33, A17, A18, A27]. On the basis of the space-time ETAS model and the thinning procedure, this paper gives the method of how to classify the earthquakes in a given catalogue into different clusters stochastically. The key points of this method are the probabilities of one event being triggered by another previous event and of it being a background event. Making use of these probabilities, we can reconstruct the functions associated with the characteristics of earthquake clusters to test a number of important hypotheses about the earthquake clustering phenomena.
We applied this reconstruction method to
the shallow seismic data in
Hierarchical Space-Time Model for Regional Seismicity [1, A2, A5, A6, A9]. A space-time point-process model is specified in which earthquake intensity is modelled as a function of previous earthquakesf occurrence times, locations, and magnitudes. Specific forms of the function of locations and times are based on the established empirical laws, such as the modified Omori formula and the Utsu-Seki scaling law of aftershock area against magnitude, but their parameter values are known to be different from place to place. Thus the parameters are further considered to be functions of spatial locations (but not time) represented by linear interpolation over a tessellation based on observed locations of earthquakes. Using the smooth representation for each parameter function in the model, a penalized log-likelihood method is used for the fitting, where the optimal weights of the penalties are objectively tuned by an empirical Bayesian method. Having done that, our final goal is to detect the temporal deviation of the actual seismicity rate from that of the modeled occurrence rate. For this procedure we estimate the space-time residual function represented by linear interpolation over a 3-dimensional tessellation based on observed times and locations of earthquakes, carrying out the similar penalized log-likelihood method. According to the estimated residual function, there are a number of zones where temporal deviation from the fitted model, with quiet periods, occurred before large earthquakes.
Space-Time Model for characterizing regional seismicity and anomaly detection [11, A2, A5, A6,
occurrence rate is modeled as a function of previous activity for which the
specific form is based on empirical laws, such as the modified Omori formula
and the Utsu-Seki scaling law of aftershock area against magnitude. Its
parameters, including the p-value of
the aftershock decay rate, can vary from place to place, showing some geophysical feature appearing
correlated with the crustal temperature. This model is used to
visualize features of the regional seismic activities in and around
this space-time model enables us to magnify anomalous periods and regions where
the actual occurrence rates deviate systematically from the modeled one. Thus,
the activation and quiescence relative to the modelfs prediction could provide
sensitive detection of stress-changes in the regions. We are concerned with
relative activation and lowering of the seismicity to explore the regions
matching the pattern of Coulombfs stress changes due to a rupture or silent
slip elsewhere. For example, such anomalies as those seen in the seismic
activity in most central
Detecting fluid signals in seismicity data through statistical earthquake modeling . According to the Coulomb failure criterion, the variation of both stress and pore pressure can result in earthquake rupture. Aftershock sequences characterized by the Omori-Utsu law are often assumed to be the consequence of varying stress, whereas earthquake swarms are supposed to be triggered by fluid intrusions. The role of stress triggering can be analyzed by modeling the 3D elastic stress changes in the crust. However, fluid flows initiating seismicity cannot be identified without dealing with both pore pressure variations and earthquake connected stress field changes resulting in complex seismicity patterns.
We show that the ETAS model is an
appropriate tool to extract the primary fluid signal from such complex
seismicity patterns. We analyze a large earthquake swarm that occurred in the
year 2000 in Vogtland/NW-Bohemia,
Model simulations are performed in which earthquakes are triggered by fluid intrusion as well as coseismic and postseismic stress changes on a fault plane embedded in a 3D elastic half-space. They reproduce the observed swarm characteristics including the temporal power-law increase of the seismic moment release. Analyzing these simulations, we find that the proposed deconvolution procedure is able to reveal the underlying pore pressure variations. This model may be applied to the swarm owing to magma intrusion [e.g., A7].
Analysis of observations on the ultra-low frequency electric field in the Beijing Region . This paper presents a preliminary analysis of observations on ultra-low frequency ground electric signals from stations operated by the China Seismological Bureau over the last 20 years. The data analyzed consists of estimates of the total strengths (cumulated amplitudes) of the electric signals during 24-hour periods. The thresholds are set low enough so that on most days a zero observation is returned. Non-zero observations are related to electric and magnetic storms, occasional man-made electrical effects, and, apparently, some pre-, co-, or postseismic signals.
To investigate the extent that the electric signals can be considered as preseismic in character, the electric signals from each of five stations are jointly analyzed with the catalogue of local earthquakes within circular regions around the selected stations. A version of Ogatafs Lin-Lin algorithm is used to estimate and test the existence of a pre-seismic signal. This model allows the effect of the electric signals to be tested, even after allowing for the effects of earthquake clustering. It is found that, although the largest single effect influencing earthquake occurrence is the clustering tendency, there remains a significant preseismic component from the electrical signals. Additional tests show that the apparent effect is not postseismic in character, and persists even under variations of the model and the time periods used in the analysis. Samples of the data are presented and the full data sets have been made available on local websites.
Microseismicity and Earthtide [15, A1]. This paper analyzes the microseismicity
in the Tanba region during the two year period following the 1995
It is known that the detection rate of aftershocks is extremely low during the period immediately following a large earthquake due to the contamination of arriving seismic waves. This has resulted in considerable difficulty in obtaining an estimate of the empirical laws of aftershock decay and the magnitude frequency immediately after the main shock. This paper presents an estimation method for predicting the underlying occurrence rate of aftershocks of any magnitude range, based on the magnitude frequency model that combines Gutenberg-Richterfs law with the detection rate function. This procedure enables us to announce real-time probability forecasting of aftershocks immediately after the mainshock, when the majority of large aftershocks is likely to occur.
 Ogata, Y., Katsura, K. and Tanemura, M. (2003) Modelling of heterogeneous space-time occurrences of earthquakes and its residual analysis, Applied Statistics (J. Roy. Stat. Soc. Ser. C.), Vol. 52, Part 4, pp. 499-509 (2003).
 Ogata, Y., Jones, L. and Toda, S. (2003) When and
where the aftershock activity was depressed: Contrasting decay patterns of the
proximate large earthquakes in southern
 Ogata, Y. (2003) Examples of statistical models and methods applied to seismology and related earth physics, International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology, International Association of Seismology and Physics of Earth's Interior, Vol. 81B, HandbookCD#2, Chapter 82.
 Toda, S. and Stein, R.S. (2003) Toggling
of seismicity by the 1997
 Vere-Jones, D. and Ogata, Y. (2003) Statistical principles for seismologists, International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology, International Association of Seismology and Physics of Earth's Interior, Vol. 81B, pp. 1573-1586.
 Iwata, T., and Nakanishi, I. (2004) Hastening of occurrences of
earthquakes due to dynamic triggering: The observation at Matsushiro, central
 Nanjo, K., Nagahama, H. and Yodogawa, E.. (2004) Symmetry in the
Self-organized Criticality, The Journal of the International Society for the
Interdisciplinary Study of Symmetry (ISIS-Symmetry) Symmetry: Art and Science
2004 (Editors D. Nagy and G. Lugosi) ISIS-Symmetry,
 Nanjo, K. and Nagahama H. (2004) Fractal Properties of Spatial Distributions of Aftershocks and Active Faults, Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, 19, pp. 387-397, doi: 10.1016/S0960-0779(03)00051-1.
 Nanjo, K. and Nagahama, H. (2004) Discussions on Fractals, Aftershocks and Active Faults: Diffusion and Seismo-electromagnetism, The Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 2004, 29, 2C, pp. 147-167.
 Ogata, Y. (2004) Space-time model for regional seismicity and detection of crustal stress changes, J. Geophys. Res., Vol. 109, No. B3, B03308, doi:10.1029/2003JB002621.
 Ogata, Y. (2004) Seismicity quiescence and activation in
 Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2004) Analyzing earthquake clustering features by using stochastic reconstruction Journal of Geophysical Research, 109, B5, B05301, doi:10.1029/2003JB002879.
 Hainzl, S. and Ogata, Y. (2005) Detecting fluid signals in seismicity data through statistical earthquake modeling, J. Geophys. Res., Vol.110, No.B5, B05S07, doi:10.1029/2004JB003247 (2005).
 Iwata, T. and Young, P. (2005) Tidal stress/strain and the b-value of acoustic emissions at the Underground Research Laboratory, Canada, Pure and Applied Geophysics, 162, pp. 1291-1308.
 Iwata, T., M. Imoto, and S. Horiuchi (2005) Probabilistic estimation of an earthquake growth to a catastorophic one, Geophys. Res. Let., 32. L19307, 10.1029/2005GL023928.
 Nanjo, K.Z., Nagahama, H. and Yodogawa, E. (2005) Symmetropy of fault patterns: Quantitative measurement of anisotropy and entropic heterogeneity, Mathematical Geology, 37, 3, pp. 277-293, doi: 10.1007/s11004-005-1559-z.
 Nanjo, K.Z., Turcotte, D.L. and Shcherbakov, R. (2005) A model of damage mechanics for the deformation of the continental crust, J. Geophys. Res., 110, B7, B07403, DOI: 10.1029/2004JB003438.
 Nanjo, K.Z. and Turcotte, D.L. (2005) Damage and rheology in a fiber-bundle Model, Geophys. J. Int., 2005, 162, pp. 859-866, doi:10.1111/j.1365-246X.2005.02683.x.
 Holliday, J.R., Nanjo, K.Z., Tiampo, K.F., Rundle, J.B. and Turcotte, D.L. (2005) Earthquake forecasting and its verification, Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics, 12, pp. 965-977, doi: 1607-7946/npg/2005-12-965.
 Ogata, Y. (2005)
Synchronous seismicity changes in and around the
 Ogata, Y. (2005) Detection of anomalous seismicity as a stress change sensor, J. Geophys. Res., Vol.110, No.B5, B05S06, doi:10.1029/2004JB003245.
 Toda, S., Stein, R.S., Richards-Dinger, K. and Bozkurt,
S. (2005) Forecasting the evolution of seismicity in
 Zhuang, J., Vere-Jones, D., Guan, H., Ogata, Y. and Ma, Li (2005) Preliminary analysis of observations on the ultra-low frequency electric field in the Beijing region, Pure and Applied Geophysics, 162, pp. 1367-1396.
 Zhuang, J. Chang, C., Ogata, Y. Chen, Y. (2005) A study on the background and clustering seismicity in the Taiwan region by using point process models, J. Geophys. Res., 110, B5, B05S18, doi:10.1029/ 2004JB003157.
In press or accepted:
 Nanjo, K.Z., Nagahama, H. and Yodogawa, E., Symmetropy of earthquake patterns: asymmetry and rotation in a disordered seismic source, Acta Geophysica Polonica, in press, Volume 54.
 Nanjo, K.Z., Rundle, J.B., Holliday, J.R. and Turcotte, D.L., Pattern informatics and its
application for optimal forecasting of large earthquakes in
 Chen, C.C., Rundle, J.B., Holliday, J.R., Nanjo, K.Z., Turcotte, D.L., Li, S.C. and Tiampo, K.F., The 1999 Chi-Chi, Taiwan, earthquake as a typical example of seismic activation and quiescence, Geophys. Res. Let., 2005 accepted.
 Ogata, Y., Seismicity anomaly scenario prior to the major recurrent earthquakes off the east coast of Miyagi Prefecture, northern Japan, and its implication for the intermediate-term prediction, Special Issue on Dynamics of Seismicity Patterns and Earthquake Triggering, eds. S. Hainzl, G. Zoler and I. Main, Tectonophysics, in press.
 Ogata, Y., Anomaly monitoring
of aftershock sequence by a reference model: A case study of the 2005
earthquake of M7.0 at the western
 Ogata, Y. and Zhuang, J., Space-time ETAS models and an improved extension, Special Issue on Critical Point Theory and Space-Time Pattern Formation in Precursory Seismicity, eds. K. Tiampo and M. Anghel, Tectonophysics, in press.
 Toda, S. and Matsumura, S., Spatio-temporal stress states estimated from seismicity rate changes in the Tokai region, central Japan, Tectonophysics, in press.
 Zhuang J., Ogata Y. and Vere-Jones D., Diagnostic analysis of space-time branching processes for earthquakes. Chapter 15 of Case Studies in Spatial Point Process Models, Eds. Baddeley A., Gregori P., Mateu J., Stoica R. and Stoyan D. Springer-Verlag, New York, in press.
T. and Katao, H.
(2003) Analysis of
a correlation between the phase of the moon and the occurrences of
microearthquakes in the Tanba plateau through the point-process modeling, Programme and Abstracts of the 2003, Fall
Meeting of the Seismol. Soc.
[A2] Ogata, Y. (2003) A practival space-time model for regional seismicity (invited), EGS-AGU-EUG Joint Assembly,Nice, France, Geophysical Research Abstract , Volume 5, 2003, CD-ROM, ISSN: 1029-7006
Y. (2003) Sesimicity-change-analysis by a space-time point-process model
(invited) The 3rd Statistical Seismology Workshop,
Y. (2003) Seismicity quiescence and activation in western
Y. (2003) Seismicity changes in western
[A6] Ogata, Y. (2003) A space-time model for regional seismicity and detection of seismicity changes (in Japanese), Chikyu Monthly, 25, 10, pp. 783-787.
[A7] Toda, S. and Stein, R.S. (2003) Earthquake triggering by volcano-tectonic events: An example from the 2000 Izu Islands swarm (invited talk), XXIII Ceneral Assembly of the International Union of Geodesy and Geophysics, 2003.
[A8] Toda, S. (2003) A Fresh Look at the Triggering of Earthquake Pairs, Such as the Landers-Big Bear, Landers-Hector Mine, Izmit-Duzce, and Nenana-Denali, and March-May 1997 Kagoshima Events (invited talk), American Geophysical Union 2004 fall meeting.
[A9] Ogata, Y. (2004) The 6th World Congress of the Bernoulli Society for Mathematical Statistics and Probability, and 67th Annual Meeting of the Institute of Mathematical Statistics, gSpace-time model for regional seismicity and detection of crustal stress changesh, July 25-29, 2004, Barcelona, Spain, (invited lecture)
Y. (2004) Statistical models of point processes and prediction and
discovery in seismic activity (in Japanese), Spring Meeting of the Mathematical
Society of Japan,
[A11] Ogata, Y. (2004) Static triggering and statistical modeling (in Japanese), The 156-th Meeting of Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction , Geographical Survey Institute, Kudan, Tokyo, February 16, 2004, Japan (topics invited lecture)
Y. (2004) Synchronous seismicity changes in and around the
[A13] Ogata, Y. (2004) Stress changes, seismicity changes and statistical models, Workshop on Seismic Activity and Probabilities of Major Earthquakes in the Kanto and Tokai Area , Central Japan, Wadati Memorial Hall, Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention, Tsukuba, Japan (invited presentation), http://kt-jisin.bosai.go.jp/WS/Program/index.html, (invited talk)
[A14] Nanjo, K.Z., Rundle, J.B. and Hollidy, J.R. (2004) Pattern Informatics and Its Application to Forecasting Large Earthquakes in Japan, Abstract for AGU 2004 Fall Meeting, Eos Trans. AGU, 85(47), Fall Meet. Suppl., Abstract NG22A-07 (invited talk).
[A15] Toda, S. (2004) Recent progress in earthquake triggering study and possible applications to earthquake prediction (in Japanese), The 156-th Meeting of Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction , Geographical Survey Institute, Kudan, Tokyo, February 16, 2004, Japan (topics invited lecture)
[A16] Toda, S., and Matsumura, S. (2004) Spato-temporal stress states estimated from seismicity rate changes in the Tokai region, central Japan (invited talk), American Geophysical Union 2004 fall meeting.
[A17] Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2004) Diagnostic analysis of space-time branching processes for earthquakes, Spatial Point Process Modeling and its Applications, Benicassim, Castellon, Spain, Spatial Point Process Modelling and Its Applications, Col-Lecco Treballis D'Infomatica/Tecnologia, Num. 20, ISBN 84-8021-475-9 Publication de la Universitat Jaume-I, Castello de la Plana, Spain, pp. 273-292.
[A18] Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2004) Visualizing goodness-of-fit of point-process models for earthquake clusters., Analysis of Natural and Social Phenomena: Data Science and System Reduction; an international workshop of the 21st Century COE program at Keio University, http://coe.math.keio.ac.jp/english/event/cherry_bud/index.html, (invited talk).
[A19] Ogata, Y. (2004) Quiescence of the 2003 foreshock/aftershock activities in and off the coast of Miyagi Prefecture, northern Japan, and their correlation to the triggered stress-changes (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 71, pp. 260-267, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A20] Ogata, Y. (2004) Statistical analysis of seismic activities in and around
Tohoku District, northern Japan, prior to the large interplate earthquakes off
the coast of
[A21] Ogata, Y. (2004) Seismicity changes and stress
changes in and around the northern
[A22] Ogata, Y. (2004) Static triggering and statistical modeling (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, Vol. 72, pp. 631-637, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A23] Toda, S. (2004) Recent progress in earthquake triggering study and possible applications to earthquake prediction (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 72, pp. 624-626, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A24] Toda, S. (2004) Seismicity changes in inland activity before and after the 2003 Miyagi-Ken-Oki earthquake and its implications (in Japanese), Chikyu Monthly, 27, 1, 56-61.
[A25] Ogata, Y. (2004) On changes of statistical distribution of focal
mechanisms of events prior to the main ruptures, Programme
and Abstracts of the 2005 Fall Meeting of
the Seismol. Soc.
[A26] Murata, Y. and Ogata, Y. (2005) Surficial density estimation from gravity data using Delaunay triangular network, Joint meeting for Earth and Planetary Science, J031-004, Makuhari, Chiba Prefecture, Japan, May 2005.
[A27] Ogata, Y.(2005) Seismicity anomalies measured by the ETAS model and stress changes (solicited), The General Assembly 2005 of the European Geosciences Union (EGU), , April 24-29, 2005, the Austria Center Vienna (ACV), Vienna, Austria (invited lecture).
[A28] Ogata, Y. (2005) Seismicity changes in western
[A29] Ogata, Y. (2005) On the aftershock activity of the 2004 earthquake of M7.4 at the southeast off the coast of the Kii Peninsula, and constraints on the fault rupture models by the mechanisms and space-time pattern of the aftershocks (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 73, pp. 495-498 Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A30] Ogata, Y. (2005) On an anomalous aftershock activity of the 2004 Niigata-Ken-Chuetsu earthquake of M6.8, and intermediate-term seismicity anomalies preceding the rupture around the focal region (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 73, pp. 327-331, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A31] Ogata, Y. (2005) Simultaneous estimation of b-values and detection rates of earthquakes for the application to aftershock probability forecasting (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, Vol. 73, pp. 666-669, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A32] Ogata, Y. (2005) Toward urgent forecasting of aftershock hazard - Simultaneous estimation of b-value of the Gutenberg-Richterfs law of the magnitude frequency and changing detection rates of aftershocks immediately after the mainshock, preprint.
[A33] Ogata, Y. (2005) Anomalies in the aftershock sequences of the 2003 Tokachi-Oki earthquake of M8.0 and the 2004 Kushiro-Oki earthquake of M7.1 and seismicity changes in the eastern Hokkaido inland (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 74, pp. 83-88, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A34] Ogata, Y. (2005) Seismicity changes in and around Kyushu District before the 2005 earthquake of M7.0 in the western offshore of Fukuoka Prefecture (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 74, pp. 523-528, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A35] Ogata, Y. (2005) Relative quiescence reported before the occurrence of the largest aftershock (M5.8) in the aftershocks of the 2005 earthquake of M7.0 at the western Fukuoka, Kyushu, and possible scenarios of precursory slips considered for the stress-shadow covering the aftershock area (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 74, pp. 529-535, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan.
[A36] Ogata, Y. (2005) Anomalies in the aftershock sequences of the 2003 Tokachi-Oki earthquake of M8.0
and the 2004 Kushiro-Oki earthquake of M7.1 and seismicity changes in the
eastern Hokkaido inland, Programme and
Abstracts of the 2005 Fall Meeting of
the Seismol. Soc.
[A37] Toda, S.
(2005) Style of stress accumulation and release in northern Honshu
Anomaly monitoring of aftershock sequences to detect lowering activity, relative to the modelled rate (the relative quiescence), is now becoming realistic and practical in predicting the enhancement of the likelihood of having a significantly large aftershock, or even another earthquake of similar size or larger occurring. In order to predict the location of a large aftershock or another proximate large earthquake, we have to assume that a significant slip may have occurred within and near to the source of the suspected earthquake due to the acceleration of quasi-static (slow) slips on the fault as the time of rupture of the major asperity approached. This is indicated, for example, by the analysis of small repeating earthquake data. Thus, we should look carefully at the activity in the stress-shadow, transferred from the slip. Such scenarios for the prediction should be useful for examining and explaining any such anomalous features.
In fact, given an anomaly of seismicity rate change,
the difficulty lies in identifying the slip location and its imminence to a
major rupture; most of them are unknown so far as no other data or constraints
are available. For probable predictions, Ogata [2005c]
explored and reported several scenarios of
stress transfers from some thinkable slips, such as that they could have been
triggered by the M7.0 rupture at 20th March 2005 off western Fukuoka
city and moreover that the stress-shadows due to the slips should, in turn,
have covered the majority of the aftershock region. These include a conjugate
fault of the main fault rupture and several known active faults near the
rupture fault. However, the largest aftershock that occurred two weeks later
was not included in the suspected scenarios. The only exception was the
predicted unlikely slip within the Kego Fault that runs through the urban area
in the city of
In any application of the (hierarchical) space-time ETAS model, the data has to be homogeneous in space and time. The threshold magnitude of completely detected earthquakes throughout a long period and wide region is high, and the number of earthquakes above such a threshold magnitude is very limited compared to the number of listed earthquakes in a catalog. This is because the detection rate of earthquakes for each magnitude is dependent on time and location. Especially, the detection rate of aftershocks is extremely low during the period immediately following the main shock, due to contamination of arriving seismic waves.
For an estimation of the detection rate in time and space, we propose utilizing the statistical model introduced by Ogata and Katsura  for the simultaneous estimation of the b-values of Gutenberg-Richter law together with the detection-rate (probability) of earthquakes of each magnitude-band from the provided data of all detected events, where both parameters are allowed to change in time. Thus, by using all the detected earthquakes in a given period and area, we can estimate the underlying ETAS rate of both the detected and undetected events and their b-value changes, taking the time-varying missing rates of events into account. It is our hope that it will become possible to give details of seismicity patterns such as aftershock productivity parameters to delineate asperities [Ogata, 2005a] over the period and region of the relative quiescence as given in Ogata et al. .
As a primary step toward achieving this objective, Ogata [2005b] presents an estimation method for predicting underlying occurrence rate of aftershocks of any magnitude range. This procedure enables real-time probability forecasting of aftershocks immediately after the mainshock, when the majority of large aftershocks is likely to occur and when the forecasting is most critical for public in the affected area.
Descrimination of foreshocks and clustering / declustering algorithms as a short-term prediction. Discrimination of foreshock sequences from other clustering activity is an important problem in short term earthquake prediction. When sequential earthquake activity starts somewhere, it can be a swarm, a foreshock sequence, or simply a mainshock-aftershock sequence. Therefore, it is very desirable to know whether the activity is a precursor to a forthcoming significantly larger earthquake or not. Ogata et al. [1995, 1996 and 1999] and [Ogata, 1999b] investigated data sets of earthquake clusters to discriminate features of foreshocks from earthquakes of other cluster types in a statistical senseCand found several features of some predictive value, including the fact that foreshocks were more closely-spaced in time than either swarms or aftershocks, the fact that foreshocks were closer together in space than other types of events, and that foreshocks' sizes were more likely to increase chronologically than the other types. By modeling such discriminating features they developed probability forecasts of an earthquake cluster being of foreshock type.
However the primary difficulty of this procedure is to find a suitable declustering algorithm for real-time forecasting of probability. There are two contrasting typical clustering algorithms, that is, the magnitude-based clustering (MBC) and the single-link-clustering (SLC) ones. The MBC based forecast performs very well, but a MBC cluster cannot formed until the occurrence of the main shock. The SLC algorithm is better for the real-time recognition of a cluster, but does not perform objectively. Recently, based on the space-time ETAS model, Zhuang et al. [2002, 2005] proposed a stochastic clustering algorithm, which appears quite useful in such a forecasting. Because of its stochastic nature, a Baysian predictive procedure will be useful.
It is becoming important to study how to make predictions and how to solve inverse problems based on the quantitative relationships between seismicity rate changes (due to the ETAS) and stress-changes. In particular, we are concerned with the theory of rate/state-dependent friction and its application to the seismicity-rate-change equation of Dieterich [Dieterich, 1994; Dieterich et al., 2000; Toda and Stein, 2003].
Inference of hazard of a fault rupture and its uncertainty from data of a small number of events, possibly with uncertain occurrence times. Conventionally, a probability of the next rupture during a future period is calculated by the predictive hazard function into which we plug the MLE values of BPT model [Matthews et al., 2002] estimated by the historical data of occurrence times. However, when the number of events in the data is small, the predictive hazard function based on the MLE usually causes a serious bias of hazard rates. Therefore, in order to see the uncertainty of estimated hazard functions, we use the Bayesian inference introducing a set of appropriate prior distributions. Furthermore, if a record of the slip-sizes of the events is available, Ogata [2001, 2002] proposes an extended renewal process for a stochastic version of the time-predictable model of Shimazaki and Nakata  by assuming the same distribution of the ratio of the time interval of the successive pair of events to the slip size of the first event of the pair. Thus, we can estimate more effectively not only the hazard function of the next event but also its uncertainty based on the occurrence time data of the events associated with the records of corresponding slip sizes.
When paleoearthquake data is analyzed, our further concern is the raw data in which occurrence times of events themselves are uncertain and given by confidence intervals or some chronological likelihood function [e.g., Sieh et al., 1989] inferred from geological evidences based on trench studies. For such records, we consider another Bayesian inference in which each uncertainty of occurrence time is interpreted as a prior distribution associated with the likelihood of a renewal process model [Ogata, 1999]. Integration of the posterior function with respect to the uncertain occurrence times and also the parameters of the renewal process model is implemented in order to compare the goodness-of-fit of competing renewal processes (e.g., log-Normal, Weibull and BPT models). Thus, the corresponding marginal posteriors of the model provide both estimates of distributions of the uncertain occurrence times and also the predictive hazard rates associated with the selected renewal process model. Particularly, in the case where occurrence time of the last event is uncertain, a natural assessment of current and future hazard of the forthcoming rupture can be provided.
There are many precise measurements such as geodetic extensometers,
tiltmeters, volmetric strainmeters, GPS and so on. However, these records are
always affected by some noises and other signals of various kinds
caused by the motions of the sun, moon, and particularly meteorological factors
such as balometric pressure, precipitation, temperature and humidity.
Therefore, it is important to model the causality and response functions of
these effects in order to know the genuine records of interest. Special care
should be put to the GPS time series data to detect geodetic anomalies
sensitively, since this dataset is now playing an important role similar to the
earthquake catalog in the sense that the stations are very densely located
Akaike, H. (1998) Selected
Papers of Horotugu Akaike, E. Parzen, Tanabe, K. and Kitagawa, G. eds.,
Springer Series of Statistics – Perspectives in Statistics, Springer,
Aki, K. (1981) A probabilistic synthesis of precursory phenomena, in Earthquake Prediction: An International Review, edited by D.W. Simpson & P.G. Richards, A.G.U., Washington, D.C., 566-574.
Dieterich, J. (1994), A constitutive law for rate of earthquake production and its application to earthquake clustering, J. Geophys. Res., 99, 2601–2618.
Dieterich, J., Cayol,
V. and Okubo, P., The use of earthquake rate changes as a stress meter at
Matthews, M., Ellthworth, W.L. and Reasenberg, P. (2002) A Brownian Model for Recurrent Earthquakes, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am., 92, 6, 2233-2250, doi: 10.1785/0120010267.
Ogata, Y. (1999) Estimating the hazard of rupture using uncertain occurrence times of paleoearthquakes, J. Geophys. Res. 104, 17995-18014.
Ogata, Y. (1999b) Real time discrimination of forshocks (in Japanese), Chikyu Monthly, No. 24, pp. 167-173.
Ogata, Y. (2001) Biases and uncertainties when estimating the hazard of the next Nankai earthquake (in Japanese), Chigaku Zasshi (Journal of Geography), Vol. 110, No. 4, pp. 602-614.
Ogata, Y. (2002) Slip-size dependent renewal processes and Bayesian inferences for uncertainties, J. Geophys. Res., 107, B11, 2268, doi:10.1029/2001JB000668, 2002.
Ogata, Y. (2004) Space-time model for regional seismicity and detection of crustal stress changes, J. Geophys. Res., 109, B3, B03308, doi:10.1029/2003JB002621.
Ogata, Y. (2005a) Simultaneous estimation of b-values and detection rates of earthquakes for the application to aftershock probability forecasting (in Japanese), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 73, pp. 666-669.
Ogata, Y. (2005b) Toward urgent forecasting of aftershock hazard: Simultaneous estimation of b-value of the Gutenberg-Richterfs law of the magnitude frequency and changing detection rates of aftershocks immediately after the mainshock, priprint.
Ogata, Y. (2005c) Anomaly monitoring
of aftershock sequence by a reference model: A case study of the 2005
earthquake of M7.0 at the western
Ogata, Y. and Katsura, K. (1993) Analysis of temporal and spatial heterogeneity of magnitude frequency distribution inferred from earthquake catalogs, Geophys. J. Int. 113, 727-738.
Ogata, Y. Utsu, T. and Katsura, K. (1995) Statistical features of foreshocks in comparison with other earthquake clusters, Geophys. J. Int., 121, pp. 233-254.
Ogata, Y., Utsu, T. and Katsura, T. (1996) Statistical discrimination of foreshocks from other earthquake clusters, Geophys. J. Int., 127, pp. 17-30.
Ogata, Y. and Utsu, T. (1999) Real time statistical discrimination of foreshocks from other earthquake clusters (in Japanese), Tokei-Suri (Proc. Inst. Statist. Math), Vol. 47, No. 1, pp. 223-241.
Ogata, Y., Katsura, K. and Tanemura, M. (2003) Modelling of heterogeneous space-time earthquake occurrences and its residual analysis, Applied Statistics (J. Roy. Stat. Soc. Ser. C), 52, Part 4, 499-509.
Shimazaki, K., and T. Nakata (1980) Time-predictable recurrence model for large earthquakes, Geophys. Res. Letters, 7, 279-282.
Sieh, K., M. Stuiver, and D.R. Brillinger (1989) A more precise chronology of earthquakes produced by the San Andreas fault in southern California, J. Geophys. Res., 94, 603-623.
Toda, S. and Stein, R.S. (2003) Toggling of seismicity by the 1997 Kagoshima earthquake couplet: A demonstration of time-dependent stress transfer, J. Geophys. Res., 108, B12, 2567, doi: 10.1029/@2003JB002527,
Utsu, T. (1977) Probabilities in earthquake prediction, Zisin(2) (J. Seismol. Soc. Jap.), 30, 179-185 (in Japanese).
Utsu, T. (1978) Calculation of the probability of success of an earthquake prediction (In the case of Izu-Oshima Kinkai Earthquake of 1978), Report of the Coordinating Committee for Earthquake Prediction, 31, 129135, Geographical Survey Institute of Japan (in Japanese).
Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2002) Stochastic declustering of space-time earthquake occurrences, J. Amer. Statist. Assoc., 97, 369-380.
Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. and Vere-Jones, D. (2004) Analyzing earthquake clustering features by using stochastic reconstruction J. Geophy. Res., 109, B5, B05301, doi:10.1029/2003JB002879.
Appendix 3: Programme of the 4th International Workshop on Statistical Seismology
In order to
demonstrate work of the Group to the committee, STATSEI-4 workshop organized by
Professor Ogata was held at the campus of the
The 4th International Workshop on Statistical Seismology (Statsei4)
Introduction and Aims
The international workshop on Statistical
Seismology (statsei) is hosted this time by the
This workshop has been held nearly biannually
since 1998 at
One of the main features of the workshop this time would be exploring the quantitative relationships between the seismicity rate changes and stress changes. In particular, we are concerned with the theory of rate/state-dependent friction and its application to the seismicity-rate-change equation of Dieterich. Therefore, we have invited Prof. Jim Dieterich to give tutorial or keynote lectures to stimulate our discussions.
More details other than described below, such as abstract and power-point oral and poster presentations, statistical soft-wares distributed at the workshop and photos, are given in the workshop home page, http://www.ism.ac.jp/~ogata/Statsei4/index.html.
The session structure consists of three themes:
Triggering; rate/state dependent friction law in relation to seismicity rate changes
Seismicity studies including statistical modeling
Predictions and evaluations including real-time and long-term probability forecast
The workshop was held from the 9th January to the 13th January.
Jan 9: Registration and ice breaking
Morning, Jan 10 -- 12 Jan: Oral and poster sessions
We had excursion during the workshop on 13th January.
The Workshop site was held at the campus of
the Graduate University for Advanced Studies, which is located on a hill top of
Ogata, Yosihiko (Chair); Tanemura, Masaharu; Tamura, Yoshiyasu; Higuchi, Tomoyuki; Iwata, Takaki; Jiancang Zhuang; Nanjo, Kazuyoshi
Sponsors and Collaborations:
Institute of Statistical Mathematics
Benzion, Yehuda (Los Angels); Chen, Yuh-Ing (
Dieterich, James (
Kitagawa, Genshiro (
Rhoades, David (
Wiemer, Stefan (
Adelfio, Giada (
Beauval, Celine (IRD - Géosciences Azur, Sophia Antipolis, France)
Bebbington, Mark (
Ben-Zion, Yehuda (USC,
Brownrigg, Ray (
Catalli, Flaminia (Istituto Nazionale di
Chen, Yuh-Ing (
Chiodi, Marcello (
Christophersen, Annemarie (
Cocco, Massimo (Istituto Nazionale di
Cochran, Elizabeth S. (UCLA,
Console, Rodolfo (Istituto Nazionale di
D'Amico, Sebastiano (Istituto Nazionale di
Dieterich, Jim (
Ellsworth, Bill (USGS,
Enescu, Bogdan (
Felzer, Karen (USGS,
Gomberg, Joan (USGS,
Gross, Susanna (
Hainzl, Sebastian (
Hashimoto, Manabu (
Hasumi, Tomohiro (
Helmstetter, Agnes (
Huang, Chi-Shen (
Imanishi, Kazutoshi (AIST, Tsukuba)
Imoto, Masajiro (NIED, Tsukuba)
Itaba, Satoshi (AIST, Tsukuba)
Iwata, Takaki (ISM,
Jiang, Minmin (
Johnston, Steven (
Kanao, Masaki (NIPR,
Katsumata, Kei (
Kawada, Yusuke (
Ma, Li (
Maeda, Kenji (MRI-JMA, Tsukuba)
Marsan, David (Université de Savoie)
Matsufura, Ritsuko (ADEP,
Matsuzawa, Toru (
Miyazawa, Masatoshi (
Murakami, Junko (SRA,
Murru, Maura (Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica, Rome)
Nalbant, Suleyman (
Nanjo, Kazuyoshi (ISM,
Neri, Giancarlo (
Ogata, Yosi (ISM,
Rhoades, David (GNS,
Rotondi, Renata (CNR IMATI, Milano)
Schorlemmer, Danijel (ETH, Zurich)
Scotti, Oona (IRSN, Fontenay-aux-Roses, France)
Shi, Yaolin (GUCAS, Beijing)
Shimazaki, Kunihiko (ERI, Tokyo)
Tanaka, Sachiko (NIED, Tsukuba)
Tamura, Yoshiyasu (ISM,
Toda, Shinji (AIST, Tsukuba)
Tsuruoka, Hiroshi (ERI,
van Stiphout, Thomas (ETH,
Veen, Alejandro (UCLA,
Vere-Jones, David (SRA,
Wang, Ting (
Wiemer, Stefan (ETH,
Woessner, Jochen (California Institute of
Yang, Wen-Hsi (
Yoshida, Akio (NIPR,
Zechar, Jeremy (USC,
Zhou, Shiyong (
Zhuang, Jiancang (ISM,
Zuniga, Ramon (Univ. Nacional Autonoma de Mexico,
- Tutorial, Utsu Memorial and Kenote lectures
(cf., the blue colored frame) are sponsored by
- We had two poster core sessions on Tuesday and Thursday. The size of the poster is 120cm in WIDTH and 190cm in HEIGHT in maximum.
- 20 minutes for each oral talk, 10 minutes for discussion.
Jan. 9 (Mon)
Evening Welcome Party
Jan. 10 (Tue)
09:45-10:00 Opening remarks
10:00-11:00 *Tutorial 1, D. Vere-Jones: Stochastic models for the analysis of seismicity data
11:00-11:30 *Utsu Memorial 1, R. S. Matsu'ura: The late Prof. Tokuji Utsu: His career with geophysics and seismology
11:30-12:00 *Utsu Memorial 2, Y. Ogata: Contributions of Professor Tokuji Utsu to statistical seismology and recent developments
Statistical Modeling and Forecasting of Earthquake 1
13:30-14:00 K. Shimazaki:
Long-term earthquake forecasts in
14:00-14:30 S. Wiemer, M. Cocco, G. Gruenthal, I. Main, W. Marzocchi, M. Gerstenberger, D. Schorlemmer: Towards an European framework for testing earthquake forecasts
14:30-15:00 M. Imoto:
Statistical models based on the Gutenberg-Richter a and b values for estimating
probabilities of moderate earthquakes in
15:00-15:30 S. Zhu, Y.
Shi: Improved stress release model and its application to earthquake prediction
15:30-15:45 Coffee break
15:45-16:15 D. A. Rhoades: Seismogenesis, scaling and the EEPAS model
16:15-16:45 S. Hainzl, T. Kraft: Analysis of complex seismicity pattern generated by fluid diffusion and aftershock triggering
16:45-17:15 Y. I. Chen, C. S. Huang: Time-dependent b value for aftershock sequences
17:15-17:45 K. Z. Nanjo, B. Enescu, R. Shcherbakov, D. L. Turcotte, T. Iwata, Y. Ogata: Aftershock relaxation for Japanese and Sumatra earthquakes
19:30-22:00 Poster Session Core Time, Group A
G. Adelfio, M. Chiodi: Earthquakes clustering based on maximum likelihood estimation of point process conditional intensity function
R. Brownrigg: A statistical seismology software suite
Y. I. Chen, C. S. Chen, W. H. Yang, K. F. Ma The relationship between the earthquake rate change and the gradient of stress change
Y. I. Chen, C. S. Huang Analysis of aftershock hazard using power prior information
A. Christophersen, E. G. C. Smith Are foreshocks really mainshocks with larger aftershocks?
B. Enescu, J. Mori, M. Miyazawa, T. Shibutani,
K. Ito, Y. Iio, T. Matsushima, K. Uehira Quantifying the early aftershock activity of the 2004 Mid Niigata Prefecture Earthquake (Mw6.6)
K. Imanishi, W. L. Ellsworth Earthquake
source parameters of microearthquakes at
T. Iwata, H. Katao The correlation between the phase of the moon and the occurrences of microearthquakes in the Tamba region
M. Kanao, Y. Nogi, S. Tsuboi Spacial distribution and time variation in seismicity around Antarctic Plate before and after the M9.0 Sumatra Earthquake, 26 December 2004
M. Murru , R. Console, F. Catalli, G. Falcone Application of physical and stochastic models of earthquake clustering to regional catalogs
Y. Ogata Relative quiescence reported before the occurrence of the largest aftershock (M5.8) with likely scenarios of precursory slips considered for the stress-shadow covering the aftershock area
Y. Ogata Toward urgent forecasting of aftershock hazard: Simultaneous estimation of b-value of the Gutenberg-Richter's law of the magnitude frequency and changing detection rates of aftershocks immediately after the mainshock
D. Schorlemmer, M. Gerstenberger, T. Jordan,
E. Field, S. Wiemer, L. Jones, D. D. Jackson From the testing center of regional earthquake likelihood models to the collaboratory for the study of earthquake predictability
S. Tanaka Tidal triggering of earthquakes
precursory to the 2004 Mw = 9.0 Off
F. P. Schoenberg Estimation of spatial-temporal point process models using the
(stochastic) Expectation Maximization algorithm and its application to
T. Wang, L. Ma, Y. Li A study on the limited power law model [abstract] [poster]
J. D. Zechar, T. H. Jordan Comparative testing of alarm-based earthquake prediction strategies
F. R. Zuniga Interevent times within aftershock sequences as a reflection of different processes
Jan. 11 (Wed)
09:15-09:45 L. Ma, T. Wang, B. Yin, W. Wang, J. Huang, C. Zhang: Exploratory statistical analysis with the data of various observations in Tangshan well
Statistical Modeling and Forecasting of Earthquake 2
09:45-10:15 D. Marsan, G. Daniel, M. Bouchon: Seismicity shadows: Observations and modelling
10:15-10:45 D. Schorlemmer, M. Gerstenberger, T. Jordan, D. Jackson, S. Wiemer, Y. Kagan, L. Jones, N. Field: From the testing center of regional earthquake likelihood models (RELM) collaboratory for the study of earthquake prediction (CSEP) experiment in intermediate-term earthquake prediction: Possibility of an M8 earthquake occurring off the coast of eastern Hokkaido in 2005
10:45-11:15 K. R. Felzer: The snowball effect: Statistical evidence that big earthquakes are rapid cascades of small aftershocks
11:15-11:30 Coffee break
11:30-12:30 *Tutorial 2 , J. Dieterich: Tutorial on stress- and state-dependent model of earthquake occurrence: Part1-model and formulation
14:00-15:00 *Tutorial 3, J. Dieterich: Tutorial on stress- and state-dependent model of earthquake occurrence: Part2-applications
15:00-15:30 M. Bebbington, K. Borovkov: Producing Omori's law from stochastic stress transfer and release
Earthquake Triggering 1
15:30-15:45 Coffee break
15:45-16:15 R. Console, M. Murru, F. Catalli: Applying the rate-and-state friction law to an epidemic model of earthquake clustering
16:15-16:45 A. Helmstetter, B. E. Shaw: Estimating stress heterogeneity from aftershock rate
16:45-17:15 S. Toda, R. S.
Stein, K. Richards-Dinger, S. Bozkurt: Forecasting the evolution of seismicity
17:15-17:45 K. Maeda: Estimation of the fault constitutive parameter A$\sigma$ and stress accumulation rate from seismicity response to a large earthquake
Jan. 12 (Thr)
09:15-09:45 M. Jiang, S. Zhou: A new multiple dimension stress release statistic model based on co-seismic stress triggering
Earthquake Triggering 2
09:45-10:15 M. Cocco, L.
Chiaraluce, Fl. Catalli: Seismicity migration and time-dependent stress
transfer: Supporting and conflicting evidence from the Umbria-Marche (
10:15-10:45 S. S. Nalbant, S. Steacy, J. McCloskey: Real-time application of Coulomb stress modelling and related issues
10:45-11:15 E. S. Cochran: Tidal triggering of earthquakes: Response to fault compliance?
11:15-11:30 Coffee break
11:30-12:00 M. Miyazawa: Dynamic triggering with no and/or little time-delay
12:00-12:30 S. Gross: Statistical measures of dynamic triggering
14:00-14:30 J. Gomberg, K. Felzer, E. Brodsky Earthquake dynamic triggering and ground motion scaling
14:30-15:30 *Keynote Lecture , J. Dieterich: Stress- and state-dependence of earthquake occurrence
15:30-15:45 Coffee break
15:45-16:15 J. Woessner, S. Wiemer, S. Toda: Correlating properties of aftershock sequences with earthquake physics
Phyisical Modeling of Eearthquakes
16:15-16:45 T. Matsuzawa, N. Uchida, T. Okada, K. Ariyoshi, T. Igarashi, A. Hasegawa Quasi-static slips before and after large interplate earthquakes inferred from small repeating earthquake data
16:45-17:15 Y. Ben-Zion, V. Lyakhovsky Analysis of aftershocks in a lithospheric model with seismogenic zone governed by damage rheology
17:15-17:45 W. L.
Ellsworth, S. H. Hickman, M. D. Zoback: Seismology in the source: The
19:30-22:00 Poster Session Core Time, Group B (see below)
C. Beauval, S. Hainzl, F. Scherbaum: The impact of the spatial uniform distribution of seismicity on probabilistic seismic hazard estimation
Catalli, R. Console: An application of the Dieterich model for seismicity rate
change to the 1997 Umbria-Marhe, central
N. Chopin, E. Varini: Particle filtering of a state-space model for seismic sequences
S. D'Amico, D. Caccamo, F. Parrillo, F. M. Barbieri, C. Lagana: Anomalies in the temporal decay of seismic sequences
S. D'Amico, D. Caccamo, A. Zirilli, F.
Parrillo, S. M. I. D'Amico, A. Alibrandi: Some analysis of seismicity in the
T. Hasumi: Spatial-temporal statistics between successive earthquakes on 2D Burridge-Knopoff model
S. Itaba, K. Watanabe: Seismicity cycle and large earthquake
S. Zhou, R.Robinson, M. Jiang: The role
of fault interactions in the generation of the 1997 Jiashi strong earthquake
Y. Kawada, H. Nagahama: Temporal power-laws on preseismic activation and aftershock decay affected by transient behavior of rocks
N. Kuehn, S. Hainzl: The effects of fault zone coupling on seismic cycling and aftershock generation
G. Neri, B. Orecchio, D. Presti: Coulomb
stress changes from grouped magnitude 7+ earthquakes in south
R. Rotondi, G. Zonno: Bayesian analysis of the local intensity attenuation
D. Gospodinov, R. Rotondi: RETAS: a
restricted ETAS model inspired by
O. Scotti, C. Clement, F. Bonilla: Earthquake recurrence models for faults: The crucial role of intermediate magnitude earthquakes in seismic hazard assessment
H. Tsuruoka: Development of seismicity analysis software on Unix, Windows and Mac OS X
T. van Stiphout, S. Wiemer: Testing the precursory seismic quiescence hypothesis
D. Vere-Jones, J. Murakami, A.
Christophersen: A further note on
A. Yoshida, G. Aoki: Enhancement and
diffusion of seismic activity around major intraplate earthquakes in
J. Zhuang, Y. Ogata: Properties of the probability distribution associated with the largest event in an earthquake cluster law
G. Zoller, Y. Ben-Zion, S. Hainzl, M. Holschneider: Properties of seismicity and surface deformation generated by earthquakes on a heterogeneous strike slip fault in elastic half space law
Jan. 13 (Fri)
(JAMSTEC 1; JAMSTEC 2)
Back to Ogatafs English Home Page
Updated on 1 November 2006